Getting Support

Keeping your professional identity during an NMC investigation

A referral can create an identity vacuum. Without noticing, many people move from "I am a professional facing an investigation" to "I am the investigation". Here is how to hold on to who you are.

Cathryn Watters Published 3 min read
Fit 2 Practise graphic: keeping your professional identity during Fitness to Practise
Quick answer

Your regulator does not control your story. During a Fitness to Practise case it is easy to become defined by the allegations. Keep a clear line between what is being examined and who you are: stay connected to your values, practice and life outside work, remember that regulatory language is not a description of your character, and look ahead to who you want to be after the case.

Key takeaways

  • Notice the shift from "facing an investigation" to "being the investigation".
  • Separate what is being examined from who you fundamentally are.
  • Words like misconduct, risk and concern describe a process, not your character.
  • Stay connected to the parts of life that exist outside work.

A referral to a regulator can create a strong identity vacuum around our careers, or how we see them. People become focused on the legal side, correcting the narrative and making sure the regulator has full context, but forget to put as much focus on who they are as a professional and what that looks like day to day. That can be extremely hard, especially when we don't know what the future holds.

Why an investigation can feel so personal

Identity is often closely tied to professional reputation, competence, ethical self-image, status, role, belonging and future certainty. An investigation touches all of them at once. Many people unconsciously move from "I am a professional facing an investigation" to "I am the investigation". That shift is the beginning of identity erosion.

Several things often happen during regulatory scrutiny:

  • you become hyper-defined by the allegations or the process;
  • ordinary parts of yourself fade into the background;
  • life narrows into waiting, defending, explaining and anticipating;
  • shame and self-monitoring increase;
  • confidence in your own judgement weakens;
  • approval from others starts to matter too much.

The danger isn't only to your reputation; it is to your sense of who you are. What helps is not denying how serious the process is, but keeping a clear distinction between what is being examined and who you fundamentally are.

Three ways to protect your identity

Hold on to your own narrative

Try not to focus too heavily on the account other people have given. Stay connected to your own experience, values and professional practice, and think about what you want the NMC to understand about your decision-making.

Stay connected to who you are

A Fitness to Practise process can easily take over your life. Your relationships, interests, creativity, values, community, faith, parenting and wellbeing all still matter, perhaps more than ever, during a difficult professional period.

Remember that language is not identity

Regulatory language can start to feel personal. Words like concern, misconduct, risk and credibility can slowly change how you see yourself. They are part of a formal process. They do not define your character, your insight or how you care for patients.

Nothing is forever. How things feel today will not be how they feel next week, next month or next year.

Try not to make rushed decisions about your future. Stay with the moment, focus on what you can control, and remember who you are. Talking it through with someone who understands, such as a mentor, can remind you how far you have already come.

If the process is affecting your wellbeing, read looking after your mental health during an NMC investigation and dealing with triggers during Fitness to Practise, or talk to us about 1:1 mentoring.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. Many people feel they have to present a careful, edited version of themselves during an investigation. Keeping time and space where you can simply be yourself helps.

You can acknowledge what went wrong and what you have learned while still being accurate about what happened. Insight is about understanding, not agreeing with every allegation.

No. Panels look for genuine, specific insight. Honest reflection in your own words is far more persuasive.

No. Feelings change as the process moves on and after it ends. Support from a mentor, counsellor or peer group can help in the meantime.

Sources and further reading

  1. NMC: Making fitness to practise more compassionate (Careline)nmc.org.uk
  2. NMCWatch: Further supportnmcwatch.org.uk

Join our newsletter to stay informed

Practical guidance on the NMC Fitness to Practise process, new articles and resources, and course updates from Cathryn and the Fit 2 Practise team. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.